He's had bad moments and makes bonehead plays for sure but he's nowhere close to incapable of producing in big moments, which seems to be what you're arguing.
He's had 10 game winning drives in his career. This year they've held the lead inside the 2 minute warning in every game. Defense let them down in the 3 losses when a stop would have won the game. The JPJ pick was bad but they still let Pittsburgh drive 80 yards.
His go ahead drive (13 plays, 72 yards, 3 minutes) against the rams late in the 4th was a thing of beauty and then the defense let the rams tie it with a fg.
1st & 10 at BAL 25
(4:41 - 4th) (Shotgun) L.Jackson pass incomplete short right to J.Hill.
2nd & 10 at BAL 25
(4:35 - 4th) (Shotgun) L.Jackson pass short left to J.Hill pushed ob at BLT 37 for 12 yards (A.Witherspoon).
1st & 10 at BAL 37
(4:28 - 4th) (Shotgun) L.Jackson scrambles left end ran ob at BLT 46 for 9 yards (J.Johnson; M.Hoecht).
2nd & 1 at BAL 46
(4:14 - 4th) (Shotgun) L.Jackson pass short middle to Z.Flowers to 50 for 4 yards (J.Johnson).
1st & 10 at 50
(3:52 - 4th) (No Huddle, Shotgun) L.Jackson pass short left to Z.Flowers to LA 39 for 11 yards (J.Johnson).
1st & 10 at LAR 39
(3:28 - 4th) (No Huddle, Shotgun) L.Jackson pass incomplete short right.
2nd & 10 at LAR 39
(3:20 - 4th) (Shotgun) L.Jackson pass short middle to O.Beckham to LA 25 for 14 yards (D.Kendrick).
1st & 10 at LAR 25
(2:55 - 4th) (No Huddle, Shotgun) L.Jackson pass incomplete deep right to O.Beckham.
2nd & 10 at LAR 25
(2:50 - 4th) (Shotgun) L.Jackson pass short left to N.Agholor ran ob at LA 19 for 6 yards (A.Witherspoon).
3rd & 4 at LAR 19
(2:44 - 4th) (Shotgun) L.Jackson pass short right to N.Agholor to LA 14 for 5 yards (M.Hoecht; C.Durant).
1st & 10 at LAR 14
(2:00 - 4th) Two-Minute Warning
1st & 10 at LAR 14
(2:00 - 4th) (Shotgun) K.Mitchell left end to LA 15 for -1 yards (C.Rozeboom).
2nd & 11 at LAR 15
(1:52 - 4th) Timeout #1 by LA at 01:52.
2nd & 11 at LAR 15
(1:52 - 4th) (Shotgun) L.Jackson sacked at LA 21 for -6 yards (B.Young).
3rd & 17 at LAR 21
(1:16 - 4th) (Shotgun) L.Jackson pass deep left to Z.Flowers for 21 yards, TOUCHDOWN.TWO-POINT CONVERSION ATTEMPT. L.Jackson pass to Z.Flowers is complete. ATTEMPT SUCCEEDS.
Monken is used to long layoffs preparing for the CFP playoffs at UGA so will be interesting to see how they come out in the second round. This team is much better balanced than the 2019 team which wasn't as good as its record.
It's funny comparing these sorts of debates to the college debates comparing teams. CFP debates, its the "whole resume" disregard individual games but now its lets ignore every game but one outlier from 3 months ago and act like it tells the whole story not the other 15.
This is only the second season he's started 16+ games. He's now had the 1 seed both times. He's legitimate if he's healthy, which he currently is, and Monken's offense does a much better job protecting him than Roman's did.