It's just an opinion. Just like yours. No need for an "actually". Nobody upset the apple cart.
ESPN playoff predictor
- Thread starter bdgan
- Start date
It's just an opinion. Just like yours. No need for an "actually". Nobody upset the apple cart.
Have people or have people not said Georgia wouldn't be in and that I'm "wrong"?
This isn't just me believing I'm right and the other side is wrong. It goes both ways hence actually. No hard feelings about it but being honest.
Of course. That's how differing opinions work. We all have legitimate points. The SEC has been highly favorable by the committee, yet the committee has never left out a P5 13-0 team.
Right so when this is said...
Let's be honest and accept we all think "so highly of our own opinions" and many have "guaranteed" they'd be out in those scenarios.
That comment was more agreeable with you than I have been on this topic.
People are listing specific scenarios UGA wouldn’t be in because you insist there aren’t any.
There are multiple scenarios they still would be in with a loss in the CCG. Again, it is too early to make a definitive statement.
An undefeated OU would be number 5. Bama wining would bump them up one if everyone other than Georgia wins, and two if one of 2-5 loses. Bama beating Georgia is not leapfrogging the Tide up to number two or three unless there are multiple losses.
And with one loss and no conference title, Georgia would most likely be out.
12-1, two-time defending national champ from the SEC isn't being left out. It won't happen.
They're saying if that happens they're out--they're every bit as insistent.
Georgia isn't falling 4 spots. No one would let alone Georgia. Yet you think that's "most likely" come on
Think about it more--you believe a 12-0 Georgia losing to an 11-1 Bama after winning back to back titles is going to fall 4 spots. FOUR spots. For losing to Bama. FOUR.
The back to back titles don't count for what is happening THIS SEASON.
Four spots because A) Georgia at that point will not have any top wins, B) Georgia will be the lone team that isn't a conference champion, & C) all the other teams would be P5 conference champions with better wins than Georgia.
Yes, it absolutely does. It's a huge factor.
Even looking at all those things--they're not falling 4 spots. No one would. NO ONE.
I don't know why this board believes the past isn't a factor. It's a huge factor. Should it be is a different discussion. Past playoff results are why the SEC always gets the benefit of the doubt.
"Benefit of the doubt" means an SEC non champ 12-1 team gets in before other 12-1 non champion teams.
It does not mean they jump other teams with better SOS, better victories, a better record, and a conference championship. Which is what you think it means.
I can see you are one of those posters who thinks getting in the last post in a thread means you "won". So congrats for "winning" with your nonsense argument.
Last edited:
No, it's means a 12-1 Georgia gets in over an ACC or Big XII champ regardless.
Again, you let me know when a 12-1 SEC team is excluded--it will NEVER happen let alone a two-time defending champ.
The fact you believe FSU, UNC or OU would be ahead of them is comical to me. You realize FSU and OU with big wins aren't even close to them right now, right? See the vote totals
Hopefully we go 13-0 and find out.
No conference will get two teams this year without the improbable happening. The Pac-12 is the only conference whose champion is a lock given how much stronger they are than every other conference.
Georgia isn't one of the top four teams of the country by any measure. They play the weakest schedule of any top ten team.
Stop ****ing assuming they’re number 1 in the cfp poll going into the seccg.
So now a 12-0 two-time defending champ won't be #1? Just want to make sure I'm following you here.
Going on record that UGA is going to be number one in the cfp until they lose?
Going on record that if they're 12-0 regardless of who else is 12-0 they're 1...teams can bounce around before
You going on record saying they won't be?
Depends who else is 12-0. I’m not the one prognosticating about them dropping from 1 to 5.
Why wouldn’t they be #1 from the start assuming they’re undefeated and everything else you say about them is true?
Because someone could jump them for a week before it self corrects as we've seen before.
Similar threads
