McSorley v. Mayfield

[Frabjous]

-Better pocket awareness? McSorley.
-Better runner? McSorley?
-Accuracy? McSorley.
-Finding secondary receivers? McSorley.
-Improvising? McSorley.
-Better Laxbro name? Baker freakin’ Mayfield.

 

[AWS1022]

-Better pocket awareness? McSorley.
-Better runner? McSorley?
-Accuracy? McSorley.
-Finding secondary receivers? McSorley.
-Improvising? McSorley.
-Better Laxbro name? Baker freakin’ Mayfield.

You forgot the big one: conference that plays no defense- Baker Mayfield.

 

[78SweetRevenge]

-Better pocket awareness? McSorley.
-Better runner? McSorley?
-Accuracy? McSorley.
-Finding secondary receivers? McSorley.
-Improvising? McSorley.
-Better Laxbro name? Baker freakin’ Mayfield.

This the most delusional post I've seen...and I hate Mayfield. Gotta give the douchebag credit--he's very f-ing good

 

[Frabjous]

This the most delusional post I've seen...and I hate Mayfield. Gotta give the douchebag credit--he's very f-ing good

Oh yeah, and only Baker Mayfield can overthrow Kim Jong-un.

 

[AWS1022]

This the most delusional post I've seen...and I hate Mayfield. Gotta give the douchebag credit--he's very f-ing good

You obviously haven't read many of your own posts.

 

[78SweetRevenge]

You obviously haven't read many of your own posts.

That's the best you've got?

 

[HazletonLion]

This the most delusional post I've seen...and I hate Mayfield. Gotta give the douchebag credit--he's very f-ing good

And i would take Trace over Baker this year and last year, the only delusion is the Heisman committee.

 

[SUPERTODD]

-Better pocket awareness? McSorley.
-Better runner? McSorley?
-Accuracy? McSorley.
-Finding secondary receivers? McSorley.
-Improvising? McSorley.
-Better Laxbro name? Baker freakin’ Mayfield.

You have some serious homer glasses on there. McSorely is one of the best in the country but no way is he more accurate than Mayfield. Stats don't bear it out. Mayfield has fantastic pocket awareness and creativity too. Keep in mind Trace has one more year in college. Let's compare what he does next year with Mayfield's 2017 season.

 

[78SweetRevenge]

And i would take Trace over Baker this year and last year, the only delusion is the Heisman committee.

lol

 

[AWS1022]

That's the best you've got?

Doesn't take much against you. In a battle of wits I'll tie half my brain behind by back to make it even.

 

[Frabjous]

You have some serious homer glasses on there. McSorely is one of the best in the country but no way is he more accurate than Mayfield. Stats don't bear it out. Mayfield has fantastic pocket awareness and creativity too. Keep in mind Trace has one more year in college. Let's compare what he does next year with Mayfield's 2017 season.

Who is ‘McSorely’?

 

[mjh218]

Mayfield has half as many interceptions as McSorely this year. If Trace can limit the silly mistakes, then he would be neck and neck w Mayfield.

As for this season, Mayfield beats Trace in completion %, yards, TDs, turnovers and QB rating.

 

[VaNtyLion]

You forgot the big one: conference that plays no defense- Baker Mayfield.

Mayfield played 1 defense all year that ranked in the top 20...only 2 in top 50. 7 of the pass defenses faced were 90th or worse.

He's an outstanding football player but there was a time we'd have lumped him in with WAC QBs given the caliber of the defenses he faced. Such players never would have sniffed New York or a Heisman.

Regardless, I will give him credit for his performance in big games. He's a gamer.

 

[Still in State College]

Really the biggest difference are the jock sniffing commentators.

 

[djr4rebs]

Mayfield is more accurate and turns the ball over less. The rest are so close that they aren't even worth arguing over.

 

[AWS1022]

Mayfield has half as many interceptions as McSorely this year. If Trace can limit the silly mistakes, then he would be neck and neck w Mayfield.

As for this season, Mayfield beats Trace in completion %, yards, TDs, turnovers and QB rating.

Spoke too soon.

 

[LaJolla Lion]

Mayfield is more accurate and turns the ball over less. The rest are so close that they aren't even worth arguing over.

As he airmailed a pass to a safety. He's just a punk that I cannot root for.

 

[AWS1022]

Mayfield is more accurate and turns the ball over less. The rest are so close that they aren't even worth arguing over.

Boom....just like that.

 

[AWS1022]

This the most delusional post I've seen...and I hate Mayfield. Gotta give the douchebag credit--he's very f-ing good

Boom!

 

[78SweetRevenge]

As he airmailed a pass to a safety. He's just a punk that I cannot root for.

I don't think anyone is rooting for him but as of this moment in time he's a better college QB than Trace McSorley and arguably everyone else in the college game. I hate the kid as much as I've hated any college player but he gets credit for his play...and gets attacked for his antics.

 

[Frabjous]

...and now Mayfield is folding like a two-dollar umbrella.

 

[78SweetRevenge]

Boom!

He threw a pick (which I'm thrilled about)...pretty sure McSorley turned the ball over slightly more in his bowl game. So far anyway. Hopefully Baker throws 3 more picks.

 

[djr4rebs]

As he airmailed a pass to a safety. He's just a punk that I cannot root for.

Boom....just like that.

I am not rooting for him either. Trace threw a similar pick against UW. Irony of the timing is fun though.

 

[AWS1022]

I am not rooting for him either. Trace threw a similar pick against UW. Irony of the timing is fun though.

Trace threw one deep in the end zone that took a very great play by the DB to make and the other was a deflection....not similar at all.

 

[Nittany1997]

Tommy Chang Part Deaux

 

[bsmith51]

As he airmailed a pass to a safety. He's just a punk that I cannot root for.

Mayfield is a ball player. He was overlooked and plays with a big chip on his shoulder. Some GM is probably going to overdraft Josh Allen and look real stupid for passing on Mayfield when Allen tanks. (Just as guys like Wilson, Prescott, Keenum, Brees , etc .have made plenty of experts look foolish).

 

[LaJolla Lion]

I don't think anyone is rooting for him but as of this moment in time he's a better college QB than Trace McSorley and arguably everyone else in the college game. I hate the kid as much as I've hated any college player but he gets credit for his play...and gets attacked for his antics.

System QB like other OU QB's who never do anything beyond college. You can think he is the greatest around right now, I'll disagree. Is he a great college QB, sure. So was Lamar Jackson and T Pryor and Braxton Miller. He plays in one of the best systems as does Trace. The problem is neither system translates well to the next level.

 

[PearlSUJam]

 

[AWS1022]

System QB like other OU QB's who never do anything beyond college. You can think he is the greatest around right now, I'll disagree. Is he a great college QB, sure. So was Lamar Jackson and T Pryor and Braxton Miller. He plays in one of the best systems as does Trace. The problem is neither system translates well to the next level.

And Tim Tebow and many others.

 

[78SweetRevenge]

System QB like other OU QB's who never do anything beyond college. You can think he is the greatest around right now, I'll disagree. Is he a great college QB, sure. So was Lamar Jackson and T Pryor and Braxton Miller. He plays in one of the best systems as does Trace. The problem is neither system translates well to the next level.

We agree on that.. He won't be successful at the next level. Neither will Trace

 

[LaJolla Lion]

We agree on that.. He won't be successful at the next level. Neither will Trace

Both remind me if career backup Chase Daniels for Brees. I can see both doing something like that. Trace has really improved with anticipation and awareness.

 

[olelion]

This the most delusional post I've seen...and I hate Mayfield. Gotta give the douchebag credit--he's very f-ing good

It's really not that delusional. They're close and Trace has another year left

 

[78SweetRevenge]

Both remind me if career backup Chase Daniels for Brees. I can see both doing something like that. Trace has really improved with anticipation and awareness.

Chase Daniel is best case for Baker. Are you convinced Trace gets a shot in the NFL? I agree his anticipation and awareness has improved but height is a huge concern with his lack of arm strength

 

[78SweetRevenge]

It's really not that delusional. They're close and Trace has another year left

They're not that close. Hopefully Trace '18 is close to or better than Baker '17. That would be great news

 

[LaJolla Lion]

Chase Daniel is best case for Baker. Are you convinced Trace gets a shot in the NFL? I agree his anticipation and awareness has improved but height is a huge concern with his lack of arm strength

He'll absolutely get a shot. Whether that is a mid round, late round, or FA shot will be the question.

 

[djr4rebs]

Trace threw one deep in the end zone that took a very great play by the DB to make and the other was a deflection....not similar at all.

It was a bad over throw. The safety couldn't make the exact same centerfield type of play because the field position didn't allow it. Bad over throws are bad over throws.

 

[78SweetRevenge]

He'll absolutely get a shot. Whether that is a mid round, late round, or FA shot will be the question.

I guess we'll see. I'd be very surprised if he's drafted but very happy for he kid

 

[steelrazor]

I dislike the kid as much as anybody but when u separate that from his football ability he is pretty dam good.

 

[bsmith51]

We agree on that.. He won't be successful at the next level. Neither will Trace

I love when people who know little about the game make definitive statements. Mayfield has as good a chance of being successful at the next level as any qb in this draft. You like to post a lot. I think you need to post less and watch more football so you can make meaningful contributions to the board.

 

[AWS1022]

They're not that close. Hopefully Trace '18 is close to or better than Baker '17. That would be great news

3,965 yard passing win 8 INT's for Mayfield in his junior year with 177 yards rushing and 6 TD's.

3,570 yards passing with 8 INT's for Trace with 491 yards rushing and 11 TD's against real defenses.

Pretty close.