ADVERTISEMENT

OT: 25th anniversary of Goodfellas, best mobster film?

simons96

Well-Known Member
Feb 3, 2013
10,119
6,858
1
Plano, TX
Tribeca film festival closed with a cast reunion of Goodfellas, celebrating its 25th anniversary

(except for Joe Pesci, who sent a hilarious profanity laced tirade to Robert DeNiro)

There was also a good article in the recent issue of Playboy, which told the hilarious story of how more than 30 people walked out of the screening after the first scene.

as much as I admire Godfather and Godfather II, I watched Scorsese's masterpiece this weekend and just marvel at its achievement as a film. Breathtaking use of music, very gritty and engaging characters, relentless and random violence, and a very exhaustive view of life as a mobster in NYC.

Ray Liotta embodies the outsider/everyman who always works on the edge of the cosa nostra because of his partial Irish heritage, but this is Joe Pesci's film. He rightfully won an Oscar as the unhinged, deranged mafia enforcer Tommy DeVito. The "you think I'm funny?" scene is one of the most tense and uncomfortable moments on film. I would say his character probably ranks #2 on my list of most fearsome criminals in film, only behind Ben Kingsley in Sexy Beast.

and yet, my favorite scene is when Karen's snooty, d-bag neighbor assaults her and Henry just walks across the street and pistol whips him in front of his friends. The scene is graphic and brutal, yet kind of amusing.

I've also mention how I cannot listen to the outro of "Layla" without thinking of the slow rolling scenes of the bodies being discovered after Jimmy Conway decides to tie up loose ends from the Lufthansa heist. (reat early role for Samuel L Jackson as Stacks, the driver.) the soundtrack of this film is a history lesson of New York covering 30+ years . . .

But this is such an incredible film, not one wasted scene, amazing use of voice overs, and the single take tracking shot from the streets into the club is pure legendary filmmaking.

thoughts?
 
Great thread.

IMO, Goodfellas is my favorite mob film--it's (based on) a true story that is simply incredible. Cinematically it's awesome, and the sound track is second to none. However, what brings it down for me is Lorraine Bracco. I thought she did a terrible job playing Karen Hill and grossly over acted the part.

Casino is probably the better movie. Sharon Stone hit a home run as the leading lady, and the film is much the same as Goodfellas.

Another underrated Scorsese flick is The Wolf of Wall Street. I'm not a big DiCaprio fan, but the movie is the exact same style as Goodfellas.
 
Godfather 1 and 2 is as good as it gets. Goodfellas next in line. No others even close to these three.
 
"You mean, let me understand this cause, ya know maybe it's me, I'm a little f'd up maybe, but I'm funny how, I mean funny like I'm a clown, I amuse you? I make you laugh, I'm here to f'n amuse you? What do you mean funny, funny how? How am I funny?"

Might be my #1 movie if I actually had to come up with one. Too many though so close.
 
When Tommy makes up the story about hitting the deer to his mom and "it's paw or whatever you call it" getting stuck always is hilarious.
 
geez almost forgot to include Spider (Michael Imperioli) . . . that mumbling, stuttering little f**k
 
Godfather 1 and 2 is as good as it gets. Goodfellas next in line. No others even close to these three.

I have nothing but respect for the ONLY TWO GODFATHER FILMS EVER MADE (rumors of a 3rd film are just stupid!), but I think they are more "polished" and grand in scale. Goodfellas really captures the authenticity and brutality of the people and the community that built the "modern" mobster.
 
When Tommy makes up the story about hitting the deer to his mom and "it's paw or whatever you call it" getting stuck always is hilarious.
Here is that scene in all its glory: Tommy the Classic Italian Memoni (Mama's boy); his glare at Liotta who won't talk, the classic description of the painting - one dog goes one way, one dog goes the other - and the guy's saying " whatya want from me?"

This scene could be in my funniest scene thread.
 
No list is complete if it doesn't include "Once Upon a Time in America". The DVD version of 3-1/2 hours, not the abomination that was released to theatres
 
Little historical trivia....

Film was supposed to be called, "Wiseguys". But CBS had a hit TV show with Ken Whal called Wiseguys. Scorsese didn't want people thinking the movie was a spinoff of the TV show. So, they renamed it, Goodfellas.

People rarely used that word. It was always, like, "What?!? You a 'wiseguy' or something?" If you ever came across someone "made", people would say, "See that guy at the bar? He's a 'Wiseguy'"
 
  • Like
Reactions: simons96
Little historical trivia....

Film was supposed to be called, "Wiseguys". But CBS had a hit TV show with Ken Whal called Wiseguys. Scorsese didn't want people thinking the movie was a spinoff of the TV show. So, they renamed it, Goodfellas.

People rarely used that word. It was always, like, "What?!? You a 'wiseguy' or something?" If you ever came across someone "made", people would say, "See that guy at the bar? He's a 'Wiseguy'"

the TV show "Wiseguy" also starred Jonathan Banks, aka Mike Ehrmantraut from Breaking Bad/Better Call Saul
 
Tribeca film festival closed with a cast reunion of Goodfellas, celebrating its 25th anniversary

(except for Joe Pesci, who sent a hilarious profanity laced tirade to Robert DeNiro)

There was also a good article in the recent issue of Playboy, which told the hilarious story of how more than 30 people walked out of the screening after the first scene.

as much as I admire Godfather and Godfather II, I watched Scorsese's masterpiece this weekend and just marvel at its achievement as a film. Breathtaking use of music, very gritty and engaging characters, relentless and random violence, and a very exhaustive view of life as a mobster in NYC.

Ray Liotta embodies the outsider/everyman who always works on the edge of the cosa nostra because of his partial Irish heritage, but this is Joe Pesci's film. He rightfully won an Oscar as the unhinged, deranged mafia enforcer Tommy DeVito. The "you think I'm funny?" scene is one of the most tense and uncomfortable moments on film. I would say his character probably ranks #2 on my list of most fearsome criminals in film, only behind Ben Kingsley in Sexy Beast.

and yet, my favorite scene is when Karen's snooty, d-bag neighbor assaults her and Henry just walks across the street and pistol whips him in front of his friends. The scene is graphic and brutal, yet kind of amusing.

I've also mention how I cannot listen to the outro of "Layla" without thinking of the slow rolling scenes of the bodies being discovered after Jimmy Conway decides to tie up loose ends from the Lufthansa heist. (reat early role for Samuel L Jackson as Stacks, the driver.) the soundtrack of this film is a history lesson of New York covering 30+ years . . .

But this is such an incredible film, not one wasted scene, amazing use of voice overs, and the single take tracking shot from the streets into the club is pure legendary filmmaking.

thoughts?

Yep!
 
Worked recreation for parts of six years at a maximum security prison in NYS. Jimmy Burke was an inmate there and I got to know him pretty well. Never told me where the money was buried though!
 
My favorite also, along with Godfathers 1&2. I think a Bronx tale is really underrated.
 
Tribeca film festival closed with a cast reunion of Goodfellas, celebrating its 25th anniversary

(except for Joe Pesci, who sent a hilarious profanity laced tirade to Robert DeNiro)

There was also a good article in the recent issue of Playboy, which told the hilarious story of how more than 30 people walked out of the screening after the first scene.

as much as I admire Godfather and Godfather II, I watched Scorsese's masterpiece this weekend and just marvel at its achievement as a film. Breathtaking use of music, very gritty and engaging characters, relentless and random violence, and a very exhaustive view of life as a mobster in NYC.

Ray Liotta embodies the outsider/everyman who always works on the edge of the cosa nostra because of his partial Irish heritage, but this is Joe Pesci's film. He rightfully won an Oscar as the unhinged, deranged mafia enforcer Tommy DeVito. The "you think I'm funny?" scene is one of the most tense and uncomfortable moments on film. I would say his character probably ranks #2 on my list of most fearsome criminals in film, only behind Ben Kingsley in Sexy Beast.

and yet, my favorite scene is when Karen's snooty, d-bag neighbor assaults her and Henry just walks across the street and pistol whips him in front of his friends. The scene is graphic and brutal, yet kind of amusing.

I've also mention how I cannot listen to the outro of "Layla" without thinking of the slow rolling scenes of the bodies being discovered after Jimmy Conway decides to tie up loose ends from the Lufthansa heist. (reat early role for Samuel L Jackson as Stacks, the driver.) the soundtrack of this film is a history lesson of New York covering 30+ years . . .

But this is such an incredible film, not one wasted scene, amazing use of voice overs, and the single take tracking shot from the streets into the club is pure legendary filmmaking.

thoughts?
A very good movie that is a permanent number 3 in top mob movies. The first 2 Godfather flicks are unbeatable
Godfather and Goodfellas are 1 and 1a.
 
Tribeca film festival closed with a cast reunion of Goodfellas, celebrating its 25th anniversary

(except for Joe Pesci, who sent a hilarious profanity laced tirade to Robert DeNiro)

There was also a good article in the recent issue of Playboy, which told the hilarious story of how more than 30 people walked out of the screening after the first scene.

as much as I admire Godfather and Godfather II, I watched Scorsese's masterpiece this weekend and just marvel at its achievement as a film. Breathtaking use of music, very gritty and engaging characters, relentless and random violence, and a very exhaustive view of life as a mobster in NYC.

Ray Liotta embodies the outsider/everyman who always works on the edge of the cosa nostra because of his partial Irish heritage, but this is Joe Pesci's film. He rightfully won an Oscar as the unhinged, deranged mafia enforcer Tommy DeVito. The "you think I'm funny?" scene is one of the most tense and uncomfortable moments on film. I would say his character probably ranks #2 on my list of most fearsome criminals in film, only behind Ben Kingsley in Sexy Beast.

and yet, my favorite scene is when Karen's snooty, d-bag neighbor assaults her and Henry just walks across the street and pistol whips him in front of his friends. The scene is graphic and brutal, yet kind of amusing.

I've also mention how I cannot listen to the outro of "Layla" without thinking of the slow rolling scenes of the bodies being discovered after Jimmy Conway decides to tie up loose ends from the Lufthansa heist. (reat early role for Samuel L Jackson as Stacks, the driver.) the soundtrack of this film is a history lesson of New York covering 30+ years . . .

But this is such an incredible film, not one wasted scene, amazing use of voice overs, and the single take tracking shot from the streets into the club is pure legendary filmmaking.

thoughts?

My favorite scene in Goodfellas is when Ray Liotta is trying to convince Paulie to go in on a club and the owner agrees that he wants Paulie in for protection from Joe Pesci. Paulie does this shrug with his shoulders and hands and screws up his eyes - it's hilarious!

Two other mobster films not to be missed is "A Prophet" and "Mesrine". Trust me on this!

Tom
 
One of my favorite "Mob" films is "A Bronx Tale". Not necessarily 100% dedicated to mob, it was a great movie.

1. Godfather
2. Goodfellas
3. Godfather II
4. A Bronx Tale
5. The Departed
6. Donnie Brasco
Oh yes, Donnie Brasco and a great performance by Pacino. Also Kill The Irishman is another excellent film
 
Last edited:
does Scarface not count? How has that not made any comments in this thread yet?

A Bronx Tale is also very very good like someone pointed out
 
Great thread.

IMO, Goodfellas is my favorite mob film--it's (based on) a true story that is simply incredible. Cinematically it's awesome, and the sound track is second to none. However, what brings it down for me is Lorraine Bracco. I thought she did a terrible job playing Karen Hill and grossly over acted the part.

Casino is probably the better movie. Sharon Stone hit a home run as the leading lady, and the film is much the same as Goodfellas.

Another underrated Scorsese flick is The Wolf of Wall Street. I'm not a big DiCaprio fan, but the movie is the exact same style as Goodfellas.
Goodfellows is a solid number 3 behind GA 1&2. Road to Predition is a possible top five nomine
 
  • Like
Reactions: rudedude
I love Goodfellas and others mentioned above. One additional movie I'd like to mention is Gangs of New York. It's a great period movie and Daniel Day Lewis plays an amazing character, as usual.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cronk and simons96
Any discussion of the best mob movies that doesn't include James Cagney and his great mob pix of the '30s is incomplete in my book

The Public Enemy



Angels with Dirty Faces

 
Absolutely incredible scene. Check out the one biker who gets out of the bar, only to have the tar beat out of him by the neighborhood guys.

"Look at me. I'm the one that did this to you".

And they STILL had a chance to walk out after the beer shower. "Now ya's gotta leave." But no. Then it was mostly bats and the goombas weren't looking for a ballgame.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fox Chapel Lion II
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT