Importance of fighting to clear Joe's name and the program's reputation > the importance of the 2017 football team winning game. To me, at least. I guess I have no football culture problem.
Of course we can and should do both. However, if forced to rank the two, I agree that Joe's name and the program's reputation is the more important of the two. It is the bigger picture. The second is one game. It is a very important game right now, but it is one game. 20 years from now, what will people focus on? Joe's legacy or this game against michigan? Even if Penn State wins on Saturday and the game is memorable, it will not go down in the lore as significant as Joe's legacy, which of course, is tied hand in hand with the program's reputation (Success With Honor, The Grand Experiment).
Joe is Joe because of decades of Success With Honor. It is not because of one game. It is not even because of 409. It is because of 409 plus all of the people on whom he had a positive impact in the university community and beyond. It is because of the contributions he made to the university, all with a sense of humility, that he is in our hearts and must be remembered and honored.
There is no separating Joe Paterno from Penn State history (the university, not just the football program). No matter how much the naysayers call us "Joebots" and clamor for Joe to be erased, Penn State and Joe Paterno are forever linked. Joe's contributions to the university as a whole are simply too important to ignore. We are because he was. There is no arguing it, though some will waste their time trying.
None of this is intended to disrespect James Franklin. That should be obvious. I have great respect for James Franklin, the man and the coach. I am grateful for the way he conducts himself, represents our university, and performs. He has turned around the football program much faster and to greater heights than I could have ever expected, all the while upholding the tradition of Success With Honor. However, there is no mistaking it. He is not Joe Paterno, not yet. He may get there, and I hope he does, but he has a long way to go. I'm sure he would readily admit that. Regardless, I support James Franklin 100% and hope he remains in Happy Valley for the remainder of his coaching career.