I'm ok with it. Shak's last two losses count, despite the circumstances, and one was a loss to Geer, who Colbray beat. Imo, a healthy Shak will be favored over a healthy Colbray, regardless of rankings.
HTH is very important, I agree, so is what-have-you-done-for-me-lately.
HTH should always take precedence, when comparing 2 wrestlers, IMO. Plus we all know Shak wasn't healthy during the losses. To rank him behind Colbray is silly. Not that any of this really matters because unlike College Football, rankings mean very little and it will all be decided on the mat. As it should be.