ADVERTISEMENT

Official Transfer Portal Thread

I think this is going to be proven incorrect. There are going to be more kids in the portal than there will be spots left to land. Transfers count toward the annual recruiting count (25). If there are 1600 names in the portal, that's 13 per school. How many schools can take 13 more kids? And how many of those spots are going to high school kids? A lot of these kids will have to return to their current schools -- if they still have a spot. Or drop down a level.
Most kids at a big school will find a place to land at a smaller program. The thing is you're basically saying you cannot cut it with the big dogs so you're basically writing off your football career beyond college which is fine. There will only be a handful of kids that enter that portal that ever amount to anything IMO...most of them being QB's as there are only so many spots to get on the field at QB. The problem may occur when the kids don't have a place to land the the original school waves Buh Bye and they have no degree.
 
Interesting name on the list. Is he the one we that Lavar is/was the legal guardian for that we recruited several years back.
Oluwole Betiku Jr., USC

See he is a grad transfer and would be eligible to play next season. I wonder if there is any interest for DL depth
 
I think this is going to be proven incorrect. There are going to be more kids in the portal than there will be spots left to land. Transfers count toward the annual recruiting count (25). If there are 1600 names in the portal, that's 13 per school. How many schools can take 13 more kids? And how many of those spots are going to high school kids? A lot of these kids will have to return to their current schools -- if they still have a spot. Or drop down a level.

I also believe that many will return to their current schools once the dust settles. That is, if their current coaches are open to them returning and have open scholarships by the time the dust settles.

PSU will likely not fill all the scholarships open due to all those in the portal. But would CJF rather award those scholarships to walk-on's or take a Grad Transfer or two from another school that was interested in being at PSU and going to a bowl. OR would he take back a player like Monroe that can play special teams and add depth. It will be interesting to see how it plays out.

Regarding how the overall scholarships play out across college football, this year, with the big number of GT's, that probably no on planned on, their likely will not be enough spots for all of them to move to the level of competition they desire. But going forward a team like Rutgers may just leave open 3-6 scholarships each year as the early signing period passes as they now know there will be some pretty good free agents that they can pick up in January and February....
 
Most kids at a big school will find a place to land at a smaller program. The thing is you're basically saying you cannot cut it with the big dogs so you're basically writing off your football career beyond college which is fine. There will only be a handful of kids that enter that portal that ever amount to anything IMO...most of them being QB's as there are only so many spots to get on the field at QB. The problem may occur when the kids don't have a place to land the the original school waves Buh Bye and they have no degree.

And one thing we don't know is how these conversations are going with each schools coaching staff. Some could really say hey, check out the portal. See if you find a starting job. And if not, you still have a spot here as a backup.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GregInPitt
Interesting name on the list. Is he the one we that Lavar is/was the legal guardian for that we recruited several years back.
Oluwole Betiku Jr., USC

See he is a grad transfer and would be eligible to play next season. I wonder if there is any interest for DL depth
They had a falling out I believe. His name stood out to me as well. Missed all of 2018 with an injury.
 
I also believe that many will return to their current schools once the dust settles. That is, if their current coaches are open to them returning and have open scholarships by the time the dust settles.

PSU will likely not fill all the scholarships open due to all those in the portal. But would CJF rather award those scholarships to walk-on's or take a Grad Transfer or two that was interested in being at PSU and going to a bowl. OR would he take back a player like Monroe that can play special teams and add depth. It will be interesting to see how it plays out.

Regarding how the overall scholarships play out across college football, this year, with the big number of GT's, that probably no on planned on, their likely will not be enough spots for all of them to move to the level of competition they desire. But going forward a team like Rutgers may just leave open 3-6 scholarships each year as the early signing period passes as they now know there will be some pretty good free agents that they can pick up in January and February....

Some good points.
 
I think this is going to be proven incorrect. There are going to be more kids in the portal than there will be spots left to land. Transfers count toward the annual recruiting count (25). If there are 1600 names in the portal, that's 13 per school. How many schools can take 13 more kids? And how many of those spots are going to high school kids? A lot of these kids will have to return to their current schools -- if they still have a spot. Or drop down a level.

Whoa- who said there are 1600 kids in the portal?
 
URL for NCAA Transfer Portal:
(Good luck logging in or getting access as a fair weather fan)

https://sso.ncaa.org/login?service=https://web1.ncaa.org/saTransfer/login/cas

----------

As of October 16, 2018 (Day after Portal was opened, there were 230 football player names in the portal.




As of January 10, 2019 there were 1608 football players in the portal.



Hopefully some of you negative Nellie's will have some closure and facts to include in your continued the sky is falling conversations.

:mad::rolleyes::D
That 1608 number in that screen shot was filtered from 4922 entries. So the true number in the portal is 4922? :rolleyes:
 
Death of college football. What coach would want to stay in the game and deal with that?
Somehow, I think there will be enough guys out there willing to put up with the transfer problems for several million $ a year in earnings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Thomas1945
Any thoughts on some Grad transfers that Penn State might have a realistic shot at bringing in.....or if they even have an interest in going that route.

I saw some names on Onward State this morning but besides saying they might visit, there wasn't much.
 
well, that is pretty much spot on. I think CJF does everything in his power to accomodate all players but there are only so many positions and snaps in a game. These kids see the game as a ticket to the NFL. If they aren't getting that ticket punched where they are, they'll go someplace else.
 
Maybe it should just be referred to as The Stargate
stargate.gif

But is it 4 Stargate or 3 Stargate?
 
this is just part of the evolution. When I was a kid, one of our best player's father was suddenly offered a govt job in Massilon Ohio. we've seen, for years, the Catholic Schools recruit kids from the state and region. More recently, common for a Fr or Soph to move to FL (or another SEC state) to go to an "academy". Then kids started planning to graduate college in three years so they could opt out, if they wanted, after graduation (see Russell Wilson). Then kids started going to college early (early enrollies, of which we have 11 this year IIRC). Then we got the early signing period to accommodate those kids. Now we have the portal...

Seems to me it is just more of the same and will get worse (or better) in the future.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MoyerJones
I also believe that many will return to their current schools once the dust settles. That is, if their current coaches are open to them returning and have open scholarships by the time the dust settles.

PSU will likely not fill all the scholarships open due to all those in the portal. But would CJF rather award those scholarships to walk-on's or take a Grad Transfer or two from another school that was interested in being at PSU and going to a bowl. OR would he take back a player like Monroe that can play special teams and add depth. It will be interesting to see how it plays out.

Regarding how the overall scholarships play out across college football, this year, with the big number of GT's, that probably no on planned on, their likely will not be enough spots for all of them to move to the level of competition they desire. But going forward a team like Rutgers may just leave open 3-6 scholarships each year as the early signing period passes as they now know there will be some pretty good free agents that they can pick up in January and February....
If I were Rutgers I’d leave open about 15 or 20 slots for January and February pickups.
 
If I were Rutgers I’d leave open about 15 or 20 slots for January and February pickups.


Yep, Rutgers' best players would be backups at the top 40 programs, so any they could get by giving them a starting position would improve their team. But 20 may be a little high........
 
Brandon Polk officially announced his decision to grad transfer this spring via Instagram and Twitter
 
Will be interesting. My opinion is the NCAA has done this to protect thier asses from getting sued by players. Marky Mark could care less what coaches think.

You do know that the NCAA is being sued by players?
 
Seeing Irv Charles on the list, I'd love for CJF to bring him back onto the team for another swing. The kid is a physical freak and the WR group could use a little experience. And mainly, he was a wrecking ball on special teams, the area of the team that needs the biggest jump in performance to get to "elite"....

Yeah I thought the same thing. I suspect that ship has sailed. Sailed probably 3 or 4 times.

Imagine what last year's team would have been like with Charles and Blacknall fully developed and deployed. Would have been a completely different team. And years from now I'm sure both of them will look back with a lot of regret.

Both of them had 1st-2nd-round type athletic talent, but just not enough brain power or self-control to take advantage of it.

But they earned their PSU degrees so they deserve respect for that.
 
Wow....not sure the NCAA or anyone else expected this kind of volume. Perhaps it is because of the pent up need. In other words, next year's portal will contain just one-year's pent up demand. Regardless, this will create a lot of evaluation and recruiting work for our (and every other) college football staff. Heck, you can field a pretty darn good team by forgetting the recruiting of high school players and just pick kids off out of the portal.

Weill be interesting to watch how this matures.
Miami is loving the portal right now. Pluck pluck pluck...
 
Did the NCAA see this coming therefore instituted the 4 game redshirt rule a year in advance?
 
And then there's that HC that enters the portal every day and sorts by Football/FBS/QB/Stats/Game Log/Passing Yards/>7 Yards/filter. Target rich my friends, target rich.
 
Last edited:
By Brian Bachman (onwardstate)
1/16/19 4:09 am

The NCAA Transfer Portal has taken the world of college football by storm and left many fans confused in recent weeks, and specifically the world of Penn State football. With seven players entering the portal since the end of the season and presumably more to come, Penn State’s depth and roster have taken big hits in recent weeks courtesy of college football’s newest revelation.

Even if Penn State is able to get its 2019 recruiting class up to a full 25 players by next month’s National Signing Day, the team will still fall well short of the 85-scholarship limit, depending on how many players in the portal leave.

This void opens the door for James Franklin to do what he does best: recruit. The Nittany Lions will need to be aggressive on the graduate transfer market. Graduate transfers are players who have completed their degrees at one university and have a year of eligibility remaining. Here are four players who can play immediately next season and that could plug some of the new holes created at Penn State.

Zach Abercrumbia, defensive tackle, Rice
Abercrumbia is one of the hottest names on the transfer market. In an interview with Rivals, he mentioned Penn State as one of the schools he’s in contact with.

Abercrumbia was an All-Conference USA player last year, recording 55 tackles for the Owls. Other schools in contact are Michigan, Notre Dame, Texas, and Mississippi State. Following Kevin Givens’ unexpected departure from the already thin defensive tackle group, expect Franklin and Sean Spencer to make a strong push for Abercrumbia as well as 2019 targets D’Von Ellies, Jaquaze Sorrells, and Joseph Darkwa.

RJ Proctor, offensive guard, Virginia
Proctor appeared in 11 of Virginia’s 13 games this year, with six starts at left guard. One of his starts was the Cavaliers’ 28-0 win in the Belk Bowl against South Carolina, a game in which he played every snap and earned the team’s highest pass protection grade per Pro Football Focus.

Improving depth on the offensive line should be a priority for Penn State after losing Ryan Bates and Connor McGovern early to the draft and Alex Gellerstedt to the transfer portal. Proctor would immediately enter the two-deep on the Nittany Lions depth chart with an opportunity to compete for a starting job at guard. He will be a grad transfer as well, meaning he could play right away this fall.

Josh Newberg of 247Sports reported Proctor plans to visit Penn State, along with Florida State and Texas.

Lawrence Cager, wide receiver, Miami (FL)
Last season, Cager led the Hurricanes with six touchdown receptions and finished second in receiving yards with 374. Both were career highs, as well as a career high 21 receptions.

Cager visited Penn State during his high school recruitment, and as a native of Maryland, has ties to the Northeast. With Juwan Johnson, Deandre Thompkins, and Brandon Polk all departing Penn State’s wide receiver room this offseason, there will be many drops snaps to replace in 2019. If Franklin decides he wants another veteran rather than fully embracing a youth movement at the position, expect Cager’s name to pop up on the radar.

With a big, 6’5″ frame, Cager is a jump ball specialist, and could serve as a useful big red zone target for the Nittany Lions.

Drew Richmond, offensive tackle, Tennessee
Richmond started 25 games at Tennessee. With Bates and Gellerstedt on the move, there’s a lot of uncertainty at the tackle position for Penn State. The opportunity to earn playing time could be an enticing draw to State College for the Memphis native.

247Sports reported earlier this week Richmond had begun following members of the Penn State coaching staff, pointing to potential interest.

Abercrumbia, Proctor, Cager, and Richmond fill visible needs for Penn State and remain at the top of Penn State’s wish list while it attempts to reload during an offseason that’s already brought more than a few surprises. Additional names will certainly emerge in the coming weeks as Franklin and his staff work to reach the 85-scholarship limit.
 
This void opens the door for James Franklin to do what he does best: recruit.
That is an interesting perspective and a way to look at this positively. I don't think anyone would deny that CJF is an excellent recruiter. That said, one could say that any opportunity for CJF to recruit even more often than he already does, might be a good thing in the end for PSU. Who knows, this whole situation is new and we are all still learning about how it will play out, including the coaches and the NCAA. But when it comes to recruiting, I have all the confidence in the world in CJF.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bison13 and 4rosco
well, that is pretty much spot on. I think CJF does everything in his power to accomodate all players but there are only so many positions and snaps in a game. These kids see the game as a ticket to the NFL. If they aren't getting that ticket punched where they are, they'll go someplace else.
In many cases the transfer has nothing to do with the NFL. If a guy has busted his butt or 3 or 4 years at PSU or any school and sees the writing on the wall that they are not going to start...they have two choices. Stay and watch or move on and hopefully play a lot of college football somewhere else for 1 or 2 seasons. Juwan Johnson is the biggest lose and there was no guarantee that he was starting. Polk wouldn't have seen the field.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Obliviax
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT