Agreed. I think the difference is one in the booth and one on the field. There has always been this controversy as to where the OC should be. The booth is great but you don't get that on-field vibe and miss the small nuance (KLS needs a breather and got dinged up for a play or two, who do we go with and how does that affect the play calling?). The booth is more strategic: this is what we should do given how they are defending us and the game situation. The sideline is more tactical: who is hurt, who needs a confidence booster, who needs a breather, what is the personnel package needed, etc.
I figure the two have to ID the play in about ten seconds so they can get it to the QB with 25 to go on the replay clock. he tells the O and they get about 15 seconds at the LOS to change or set and go. Something like this concluding a second down play
- booth coach: looks like the refs are going to mark it as 3rd and 3, maybe 4
- field coach: KLS took a shot on his block and needs a play
- booth: defense has been running a single safety on film and in these situations, with a five man front
- field coach: quick out to the WR?
- booth: not with KLS out. Lets go with a TE dig over the middle with a slant behind him as option 2. RB, is the underneath option (of course, this would just be a play). Lets get Singeton on the field and get Kaytron off.
- field: OK, that means we'll need formation X with two TEs and two WRs. good?
- booth: good
- field: (yelling) team package X, team package X...two TEs and two WRs, Singleton in.
- Field: to signalcallers: package X, formation Y, play Z
- Allar: Huddle, formation Y, play Z on go!
- booth: defense came out in a nickel formation. two S deep. switch off to TE bubble screen? Out of this package this is our best option
- Field: Agreed
- Field: Check, Check, Check....Field coach tells signal callers to play
- Allar: Check, Check, Check...Omaha, Omaha, Omaha. Team resets
- Ball is hiked and play is executed.
Is that about right?