Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Honoring all who served in any war, allies and enemies alike. Most of them fought because they were ordered to. Most of them didn’t know what was really going on - THE BIG WHY.
What did Jason Bourne say to the guy about to shoot him on that roof, with nowhere to go but dead?
“Do you even know why you’re supposed to kill me?”
Thanks for derailing a perfectly respectful and appropriate thread.Honoring all who served in any war, allies and enemies alike. Most of them fought because they were ordered to. Most of them didn’t know what was really going on - THE BIG WHY.
What did Jason Bourne say to the guy about to shoot him on that roof, with nowhere to go but dead?
“Do you even know why you’re supposed to kill me?”
https://en.m.wikiquote.org/wiki/Smedley_Butler
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smedley_Butler
Ranger, I don't think he derails the thread. We can still respect our troops and veterans without necessarily agreeing with the necessity of a war(s).Thanks for derailing a perfectly respectful and appropriate thread.
I have no problem with you expressing your opinion. I do question your timing. Your issue appears to be with those who prosecute wars, not with those who fight them. Today we honor the latter.I didn’t derail anything. I expressed my opinion . You don’t like it, too bad. As I see it, we are all one. The ‘we’ making the decisions has always and forever been the problem; ruined the world.
I am appreciative of American veterans. I also believe that persons not American, in war, are there for the same reason - they were told to kill and don’t ask why.
‘All Quiet on the Western Front’ is a good and enlightening read. It was written by a German soldier but could just as well have been written by an American.
I have to disagree. It’s like saying bad stuff about someone at their funeral. There is a time and a place for intelligent discourse about the pros and cons of war, but saying “thanks for your service, but war is bad” completely undermines the appreciation.Ranger, I don't think he derails the thread. We can still respect our troops and veterans without necessarily agreeing with the necessity of a war(s).
The irony is that those who we honor today especially those who paid the ultimate price did so to give even those with dissenting thoughts the freedom to express them.I have no problem with you expressing your opinion. I do question your timing. Your issue appears to be with those who prosecute wars, not with those who fight them. Today we honor the latter.
There is no need to delete the post, nor is there a need to call me shallow based upon a few lines on a messsge board. I am, at times, critical of the opinions of others on this board, but I try to avoid attacks on those who made them. I generally read the posts you make here and I will continue to do so. We can disagree without making it personal.Do we honor the Lakota, the Cherokee and other native tribes who. were vetrrans of a different kind of war? Were their lives somehow less valuable than those invaders/:colonists who mass killed them? Are the half million innocent Iraqis, people like us, also veterans of war?
I’m no better than a typical Iraqi, Lebanese, Armenian or any other. Neither are you. We are Americans only by way of some inexplainable random occurrence and a dumb British king. That is it.
I’ll delete the post that offended you so much. Stay safe ... and shallow.
The irony is that those who we honor today especially those who paid the ultimate price did so to give even those with dissenting thoughts the freedom to express them.
Do we honor the Lakota, the Cherokee and other native tribes who. were vetrrans of a different kind of war? Were their lives somehow less valuable than those invaders/:colonists who mass killed them? Are the half million innocent Iraqis, people like us, also veterans of war?
I’m no better than a typical Iraqi, Lebanese, Armenian or any other. Neither are you. We are Americans only by way of some inexplainable random occurrence and a dumb British king. That is it.
I’ll delete the post that offended you so much. Stay safe ... and shallow.
Sometimes the right approach is to keep your thoughts to yourself.
but there is one in every crowdSometimes the right approach is to keep your thoughts to yourself.
Do we honor the Lakota, the Cherokee and other native tribes who. were vetrrans of a different kind of war? Were their lives somehow less valuable than those invaders/:colonists who mass killed them? Are the half million innocent Iraqis, people like us, also veterans of war?
I’m no better than a typical Iraqi, Lebanese, Armenian or any other. Neither are you. We are Americans only by way of some inexplainable random occurrence and a dumb British king. That is it.
I’ll delete the post that offended you so much. Stay safe ... and shallow.
Do we honor the Lakota, the Cherokee and other native tribes who. were vetrrans of a different kind of war? Were their lives somehow less valuable than those invaders/:colonists who mass killed them? Are the half million innocent Iraqis, people like us, also veterans of war?
I’m no better than a typical Iraqi, Lebanese, Armenian or any other. Neither are you. We are Americans only by way of some inexplainable random occurrence and a dumb British king. That is it.
I’ll delete the post that offended you so much. Stay safe ... and shallow.
Dont delete it. I liked it and agreed with it.
And any self respecting veteran would tell you he (or she) fought for your right to dissent from popular opinion and thought.
That is not the point. There is a time and place for that. Today is a day to honor and thank Vets, not to debate the merits of war. Go to the test board this coming week and debate it all you want. Hell. Don't wait. Start a thread today. I just think a thread to honor vets should stand alone. I don't oppose debates on wars, but I would not show up at a military funeral and start one. Everthing has it's time and place.
I did not see it. I reread all his posts in this thread and still do not see it. I would be critical of any posts contrary to the point of the thread...thanking and honoring American Veterans.Ok-everything has its time and place?
How about you admonish Ranger Dan for making a negative comment at a former Commander in Chief and family on this thread? For the same reason-time and place.
Or do the rules of this thread only apply to a select few?
ro, I looked for it also and can't find it. Sure it wasn't on another thread?Ok-everything has its time and place?
How about you admonish Ranger Dan for making a negative comment at a former Commander in Chief and family on this thread? For the same reason-time and place.
Or do the rules of this thread only apply to a select few?
I did not see it. I reread all his posts in this thread and still do not see it. I would be critical of any posts contrary to the point of the thread...thanking and honoring American Veterans.
Agree with your statement on Vietnam. A good percentage of my company were college grads, including me. I would say 20-25%.I believe it is inappropriate to use this day for "Honoring all who served in any war, allies and enemies alike." I will limit my "honoring" to American veterans.
I would also take issue with the two sentences that follow that one, but I will leave that debate for another time.
I will use your post to bring up a few points about the Vietnam War that many Americans may not realize. There is a perception that most of those who fought in Vietnam were draftees. In fact, 2/3rds of the men who served in Vietnam were volunteers. Approximately 70% of those killed were volunteers. There is also a perception that the War was largely fought by uneducated minorities, yet 86% of those who died were white and Vietnam Vets were the most educated of any war in our history, 79% having a high school education or better.
(source for all the above is History.com. )
Link: http://www.vhfcn.org/stat.html
Link:
http://philippine-defenders.lib.wv.us/html/bataan.html
"Death March" by Soldier Poet Henry Lee
So you are dead. The easy words contain
No sense of loss, no sorrow, no despair.
Thus hunger, thirst, fatigue, combine to drain
All feeling from our hearts. The endless glare,
The brutal heat, anesthetize the mind.
I can not mourn you now. I lift my load,
The suffering column moves. I leave behind
Only another corpse, beside the road.
Hell Ship Clyde Maru (my father is listed on this roster)
SZCZEPANSKI JOSEPH LEON;Pfc;6897719;AC;Hq & Hq Sqdn;20th Air Base Gp;FEAF;194;;;
Hellships
As military success began to place greater demands on Japan's far-flung armed forces, the Japanese Prisoner of War Bureau, at the request of the Japanese industrialists, hastened the transfer of American and other Allied POW's to Japan and other areas to replenish their labor pool. Most of the Japanese ships transporting POW's were old and unseaworthy. The conditions were shocking and inhumane. At least 25 ships carrying Allied prisoners of war were sunk due to enemy action. On these ships there were a total of 18,901 prisoners of war being transported. Of this total, 10,853 were determined to have died because of submarine and air attacks--3,632 of them Americans. The number that died because of lack of food, sanitary conditions, medical supplies and attention, and brutal treatment by their Japanese captors has never been revealed. The death count of prisoners of war on these hellships was astounding. Japanese records disclose that these ships had the ultimate destination of Japanese industrialists to be used as slave labor.[/QUOTE Sorry to hear about your father, I'm sure he would be proud of you.
I honor all Veterans, but I have an enduring admiration for those who served in combat. Drafted or not, It appears you served your country with distinction. Thank you.Firstly I was drafted, so I'm no hero. Secondly, after we lost a platoon RTO, and I can't recall how our company commander knew I was a college graduate, he reasoned I would make a decent RTO. I refused as, when the NVA ambushed (frequently) they would look for the RTO (the antenna), knowing the man in front of them was an officer. RTOs hit often. Plus I guess reducing communication a big factor too. However, in their enthusiasm and haste they probably started swinging the AK a second sooner than pulling the trigger. It was the same with the point. Point man often missed but the guy behind got it. Anyway, so I was ordered in the field to become an RTO. Again, no hero! They made the right choice in that, for some reason I knew phonetic alphabet really well from advanced infantry training. Shortly after I joined our unit we "lucked" into several contacts and began to get this reputation. So it was like a snow ball. NVA would be spotted and in we would go. How often? Every 25 flights you are awarded an Air Medal. I have two. I became friends at PSU and later work, with several infantry men, including Marines and they were astonished at the number of firefights I was in. Our crowning achievement was the taking of the NVA cash "Shakey's Hill" (CBS was with us and there is a documentary made, I still never bought it) in Cambodia in May of 70. Normally six ships (hueys) would go back and forth two or three times to drop you into an area. That day in May, 64 ships in the air at once. Shock and awe I guess. We went in with over 70 some and walked out with less than 50. I was hit, got two days of IV antibiotics and was back with my unit in time to walk out.
Firstly I was drafted, so I'm no hero. Secondly, after we lost a platoon RTO, and I can't recall how our company commander knew I was a college graduate, he reasoned I would make a decent RTO. I refused as, when the NVA ambushed (frequently) they would look for the RTO (the antenna), knowing the man in front of them was an officer. RTOs hit often. Plus I guess reducing communication a big factor too. However, in their enthusiasm and haste they probably started swinging the AK a second sooner than pulling the trigger. It was the same with the point. Point man often missed but the guy behind got it. Anyway, so I was ordered in the field to become an RTO. Again, no hero! They made the right choice in that, for some reason I knew phonetic alphabet really well from advanced infantry training. Shortly after I joined our unit we "lucked" into several contacts and began to get this reputation. So it was like a snow ball. NVA would be spotted and in we would go. How often? Every 25 flights you are awarded an Air Medal. I have two. I became friends at PSU and later work, with several infantry men, including Marines and they were astonished at the number of firefights I was in. Our crowning achievement was the taking of the NVA cash "Shakey's Hill" (CBS was with us and there is a documentary made, I still never bought it) in Cambodia in May of 70. Normally six ships (hueys) would go back and forth two or three times to drop you into an area. That day in May, 64 ships in the air at once. Shock and awe I guess. We went in with over 70 some and walked out with less than 50. I was hit, got two days of IV antibiotics and was back with my unit in time to walk out.
What a long, strange trip it's been from the 1970s to today
Dont delete it. I liked it and agreed with it.
And any self respecting veteran would tell you he (or she) fought for your right to dissent from popular opinion and thought.