Andy Katz said, on the B1G Network, that the Lions should play week night games at Rec Hall, and weekend games at BJC. Discuss.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I posted in another thread that if PSU had played every Big 10 game at Rec Hall this season, they probably would've won every one; that's how important it is to be in that type of setting.Andy Katz said, on the B1G Network, that the Lions should play week night games at Rec Hall, and weekend games at BJC. Discuss.
That's totally overstating the home court advantage that Rec Hall gives us.I posted in another thread that if PSU had played every Big 10 game at Rec Hall this season, they probably would've won every one; that's how important it is to be in that type of setting.
That's totally overstating the home court advantage that Rec Hall gives us.
Agree that it sucks for recruiting and players, but it also gives an advantage to us in that we're used to playing in that environment, and our opponents usually aren't. We've got the 76th best HCA in the country, and 7th in the B1G based on Pomeroy's numbers.It’s overstating it but it’s not totally wrong.
PSU bball can’t fill the BJC, especially on weeknights. It can be cavernous, empty and dull which doesn’t attract new fans and can be a deadly environment to play in for players (and future recruits visiting).
Agree that it sucks for recruiting and players, but it also gives an advantage to us in that we're used to playing in that environment, and our opponents usually aren't. We've got the 76th best HCA in the country, and 7th in the B1G based on Pomeroy's numbers.
But I'd say it's "wrong" in that even if Rec Hall was giving us an enormous bump, it might be worth another 2 points over the worst home court in the country (and likely isn't worth close to that over the BJC). We've already lost games by 9, 4, and 9. Moving them to Rec Hall isn't a 10 point difference to overcome that.
Noticed this trend as well, as we do knock off some good teams in there and I've read on other boards that teams hate playing there. It's like a sports psy-op for some teams. Works for us as well as against us, as would Rec Hall. There are pros and cons to anything.Agree that it sucks for recruiting and players, but it also gives an advantage to us in that we're used to playing in that environment, and our opponents usually aren't.
In 95-96, the BJC was a fantastic atmosphere when it was packed every game. But I've finally realized that even putting a really good team on the court isn't enough to overcome our geographical obstacles (and the lack of college hoops fandom in our fanbase)...we're still not going to regularly pack the BJC for a weeknight game, and 95-96 was a flash in the pan mostly due to the "newness" of the BJC.Noticed this trend as well, as we do knock off some good teams in there and I've read on other boards that teams hate playing there. It's like a sports psy-op for some teams. Works for us as well as against us, as would Rec Hall. There are pros and cons to anything.
People of a certain age recall when the BJC first opened and the team was pretty good, it was a loud and boisterous atmosphere when there were 10 or 12K+ in there. We all know the manifold reasons people don't show up, it's been discussed to death. Job 1 is to win.
I don't know if it is totally overstating it. A little probably. We may only lose 3 of 10 home games so Rec Hall could maybe have made 2 of those losses (say NW and Minny) at BJC wins. Not bad.That's totally overstating the home court advantage that Rec Hall gives us.
Again, moving from the BJC to Rec Hall isn't going to turn a 9 point loss into a win. Home court doesn't swing things nearly that much.I don't know if it is totally overstating it. A little probably. We may only lose 3 of 10 home games so Rec Hall could maybe have made 2 of those losses (say NW and Minny) at BJC wins. Not bad.
My point is that NW and Minny maybe don't make those huge runs on us in Rec Hall. Maybe they do, who knows. Yeah, we could have very well lost last night too so there are both sides to it.Again, moving from the BJC to Rec Hall isn't going to turn a 9 point loss into a win. Home court doesn't swing things nearly that much.
And who knows, play everything in Rec Hall and we might drop the Wisconsin or Ohio State game that we won at the BJC (if we're getting into theoreticals).
And maybe Kanye doesn't run into the Minny player, get concussed,we win and then he doesn't spiral down the drain.My point is that NW and Minny maybe don't make those huge runs on us in Rec Hall. Maybe they do, who knows. Yeah, we could have very well lost last night too so there are both sides to it.
You're only talking about theoreticals. Where does the 2 pt advantage number come from? Playing in REC clearly gives us an advantage in certain situations. How much is impossible to say. Illinois was a 7.5 point favorite so by your logic they would have been a 9.5 pt favorite in BJC?Again, moving from the BJC to Rec Hall isn't going to turn a 9 point loss into a win. Home court doesn't swing things nearly that much.
And who knows, play everything in Rec Hall and we might drop the Wisconsin or Ohio State game that we won at the BJC (if we're getting into theoreticals).
I think we’d have a pretty similar chance of winning in the BJC…we’ve knocked off our last four ranked opponents at home, and three of those were on the East side of campus.We can talk theoreticals about how many points Rec Hall means for eons, but let's use the "eye test" - is there anyone who thinks Penn State wins last night's game if it was played at the BJC? No, didn't think so.
I’m looking from a handicapping standpoint…those that are using custom HCA would likely have a spread of about 2 between the worst HCA in the country and the best. As for Wednesday night…we also would have been a 7.5 to 8 point dog at the BJC, as no one is adjusting their numbers for that change.You're only talking about theoreticals. Where does the 2 pt advantage number come from? Playing in REC clearly gives us an advantage in certain situations. How much is impossible to say. Illinois was a 7.5 point favorite so by your logic they would have been a 9.5 pt favorite in BJC?
Yeah. They’ve never overcome a double digit lead at the BJC. Oh, wait……On the other hand, I watched us blow a double digit lead vs Princeton in Rec Hall.We can talk theoreticals about how many points Rec Hall means for eons, but let's use the "eye test" - is there anyone who thinks Penn State wins last night's game if it was played at the BJC? No, didn't think so.
Let Andy Katz pay for the added expenses. As an example do you have any idea what it cost to lay down the BB floor and remove ?Andy Katz said, on the B1G Network, that the Lions should play week night games at Rec Hall, and weekend games at BJC. Discuss.
If you watched the video of it going down, the answer is not very muchLet Andy Katz pay for the added expenses. As an example do you have any idea what it cost to lay down the BB floor and remove ?
like how they dominated a 8-6 ivy league Princeton team there....ooops they lost that game.I posted in another thread that if PSU had played every Big 10 game at Rec Hall this season, they probably would've won every one; that's how important it is to be in that type of setting.
Which just like the white out if done every game the novelty will wear off very quickly. You will quickly see a half empty Rec Hall. If Rec Hall was such a home court advantage why did we lose so many games there? Penn State was 12-15 at home in 3 season there.It’s overstating it but it’s not totally wrong.
PSU bball can’t fill the BJC, especially on weeknights. It can be cavernous, empty and dull which doesn’t attract new fans and can be a deadly environment to play in for players (and future recruits visiting).
The Rec Hall atmosphere makes it more intimate and special. It would help to build the program and create interest. As it becomes more crazy it’ll attract more students and fans (much like the white out has in football). Create the enthusiasm and the ‘show’ aspect of the game at PSU.
Well how are you going to make up the lost revenue? Who going to put up the millions to build locker rooms for the team along with training rooms ect. Meanwhile they will still need to keep all the facilities at the BJC because there is no room to practice at rec hall.How many weekends does PSU play at home??? Not many Saturdays. Put the women in there too! But it won’t happen because essentially the BB programs are tenants of the BJC which is owned by PSU and the university ain’t missing that money… many more events would come to area in the winter if the BJC was available. Bottom line PSU doesn’t care enough about BB to make any changes. They just don’t.
I assume you are going to donate the several million to expand rec hall to build locker room and other facilities for the teams? You can’t have them playing there full time dressing in temporary locker rooms. So now they have two locker rooms to maintain because there is not room in rec for them to practice.If you watched the video of it going down, the answer is not very much
On the other hand does anyone think Penn State maintains the same atmosphere there after the novelty wears off? The environment of a one off game is not going to carry to every home game. I give it a year before Penn State is playing in a half full Rec Hall.We can talk theoreticals about how many points Rec Hall means for eons, but let's use the "eye test" - is there anyone who thinks Penn State wins last night's game if it was played at the BJC? No, didn't think so.
Which just like the white out if done every game the novelty will wear off very quickly. You will quickly see a half empty Rec Hall. If Rec Hall was such a home court advantage why did we lose so many games there? Penn State was 12-15 at home in 3 season there.
Big Ten Record at home
92/93 1-8
93/94 5-4
94/95 6-3
Is a half empty Rec Hall a much better atmosphere? People falsely think that every game would be like the Illinois game. In reality the arena would be half empty just like the BJC. Keep in mind at the time Rec Hall had a capacity of 8,500 and the best season had 6,666.Never said it would guarantee wins, just that it would be a much better atmosphere than the half empty and poorly constructed BJC.
Is a half empty Rec Hall a much better atmosphere? People falsely think that every game would be like the Illinois game. In reality the arena would be half empty just like the BJC. Keep in mind at the time Rec Hall had a capacity of 8,500 and the best season had 6,666.
Average Season Att. Games
1. 6,666 1994-95 106,648 16
2. 6,461 1993-94 90,458 14
3. 6,119 1992-93 79,545 13
4. 6,095 1965-66 54,850 9
5. 5,873 1990-91 82,217 14
Honestly I wish Penn State would have renovated the BJC into a hockey arena which I think would fit in better there. Then built a basketball only facility. I always thought USC Galen Center would have been the perfect model. It is a small field house type arena that seats 10,258 which would be perfect size. Imagine this with the open glass facing mount nittany.
A 10,000 seat field house would be awesome and not just for basketball.
I agree a basketball only arena would be better. Problem is, PSU doesn’t have a 10,000 seat arena like USC or Colorado and it’s not happening anytime soon. Since the university owns the BJC, it has no incentive to build a new arena and lose their main ‘tenants’ of the BJC.
At this point I don’t see the argument of keeping things as they are and refusing to use RecHall during the week. If the whole argument is the atmosphere at Rec will decrease over time, I disagree. It was always superior to the BJC IMO but even if it does, what have you lost? Nothing. It just equals the current atmosphere at the BJC.
They need to shake something up. It’s been 30 years of futility while continuing to do the same thing and expecting different results.