For anyone who cares, National Geographic continues to try to beat a particular drum, facts be damned:
Tension between schools fake news?
Racial tension between Hazleton Area and Crestwood students is alleged in an Instagram post from National Geographic magazine.
The Instagram post references an article in the magazine’s April edition — devoted entirely to race — about the impact of the growing nonwhite population in the U.S. and the growing Latino population in Hazleton.
The article does not mention Crestwood.
The Instagram post shows photos of Hazleton Area football players from an October game at Crestwood and says they were nervous about “playing the ‘uppity white school’ where racial slurs had been yelled at them during basketball games.”
“I have heard nothing of the sort to me,” Hazleton Area football coach Mike Brennan said. “That’s totally news to me.”
Hazleton Area Principal Rocco Petrone, a former football coach, is mentioned in the Instagram post and the article.
He said Monday he hasn’t seen either.
“I never heard anything like that,” Petrone said referring to the Instagram post. “I’ve never heard anyone from Crestwood say anything derogatory.”
The post from Saturday had more than 150,000 “likes” by Monday afternoon. It says a cheerleading coach heard Crestwood students scream, “Get a green card.”
Hazleton Area High School’s student population is 51 percent Hispanic and 46 percent white, according to the state Department of Education. Crestwood has a white population of 92 percent.
A cutline to a photograph in the magazine says Petrone “said the team was mostly white 15 years ago.”
“I would never say that,” Petrone replied, adding the football team is “more diverse” today.
It was not a direct quote, and the cutline also says “almost half of the players are minorities.” The Instagram post contains the same information.
“Our students accept diversity and get along very well with each other,” Petrone said. “I’m proud we get along so well in extra-curricular activities and athletics.”
The Instagram post didn’t name anyone alleging racial tension between Hazleton Area and Crestwood. The article includes named sources quoted talking about race and the growing Latino population in Hazleton.
Crestwood Superintendent Joseph Gorham questioned if the magazine did any “source and fact checking” into “pretty serious claims” noted in the Instagram post. In an email, Gorham noted football season precedes basketball season and recalled talking to Hazleton Area basketball players in the hallway before their last game at Crestwood.
“They were looking for our visitor locker rooms as I was passing by,” Gorham said. “The Hazelton boys were polite, respectful and engaging. The entire group and I chatted for quite some time and we laughed together. They have a great group of kids!”
National Geographic didn’t return a phone message and email seeking comment.
Contact the writer:
mbuffer@citizensvoice.com
570-821-2073, @cvmikebuffer