I disagree. Pletch is an excellent wrestler -- really elite. Willie had a really nice comment about him after FloNationals (I think that was the event), about how he just lets it all hang out there/goes for it, and isn't concerned about rankings.
Are you concerned because Pletch got pinned by Red at FloNationals? He had a great tourney until that point, and made a mistake not unlike what DT did against Bubba at Nationals in 2011. Pletch had a great run at States, but ended up losing in ultimate tiebreaker to AC Headlee. The SV period in that match was just amazing. How Pletch avoided the TD by Headlee is beyond me, and then how he didn't score a TD himself was a stunner (give some credit to Headlee). Pletch has pretty much dominated everyone for a few years, with the exception of the aforementioned, and his 2014 FloNationals final against Nick Piccininni. IMHO, you are splitting hairs where it isn't really warranted. Piccininni seemed all-world at the time of the '14 FloNationals match, but he hasn't been all-world since that match.
Excluding Spencer Lee, I don't think any of the top lightweight guys are off-the-charts, guaranteed future NCAA champs. There are a few of them, including the ones I mentioned above and Pletch, that are likely to be in contention to AA or win at NCAAs for 3/4 years at 125, 133, 141.
I've stated many times that I dislike projecting weights, as it's so difficult to do unless you have a lot of inside info about a kid's weight, his parents, etc. With that caveat, it's my uninformed opinion that Pletch would have a tough time making 125 in college. I see him at 133, with 141 a possibility. To me, that's a good thing (for PSU) as my projections for Spencer Lee are that he'll never exceed 125 in college. My hope is that PSU gets a verbal from somebody that can go 125, and somebody that can go 133 as true freshman, and then lands Spencer and has the aforementioned do a combination of redshirting or moving up a weight class.
There are so many ways this can play out. IMHO, all of the names that we've discussed on this board would be excellent additions to the roster, and would do a great job for PSU at 125 and 133.